1951—Stan “The Man” Musial*, Bert Rechichar*
1952— P.G. Hayes*, Pat Mullin*, Jim Russell*
1953— Tom Brown*, Jim Hamer*, Bill Parkinson, Sr.*
1954 No Selections
1955— Joe Connell*, Arnold Galiffa*, James K. Russell*
1956— Michael “Ki” Duda, Ed. D.*, Ed Roebuck*, Rev. “Deacon” Dan Towler*
1957— Floyd M. France*, Tom Preston*, Steve Stepanian*
1958— Thomas Barbero*, M.H. Heatter, M.D.*, John T. Matta*
1959— Thomas Parkinson, D.D.S.*, Harry R. Sickels*, G. Harold “Doc” Smith*
1960— William J. “Billy” Long*, John G. “Scissors” McIlvain*, Charles H. “Jerry” Wunderlich*
1961— Carl “Head” Aschman*, Earl “Skykes” Bruce*, John P. “Moon” Clark*, Nick Kotys*
1962— Preston A. Ditty*, Pete Garnic*, Clyde B. Smith*
1963— Neil Brown*, John Potsklan*, Sever J. Toretti*
1964— H.C. “Doc” Carlson, M.D.*, Louis C. “Bimbo” Cecconi, Leslie “Bus” Edwards*, Armand J. Niccolai*
1965— George Humphries*, Harry P. “Yi” McCurdy*, William T. “Vince” Stapulis*, Kenneth L. Stilley*
1966— Chuck Drazenovich*, Arthur E. Feldman*, Nestor E. Henrion*, John R. Martak*
1967— Alvin “Dutch” Biddle*, R. James “Rab” Currie*, Robert B. “Bob” Davis*, Stewart S. Townsend*
1968— John R. Bunardzya*, John W. Butler*, James P. “Pat” Herron*, Wade Wilson, Ed. D*
1969— James”Toots” Fillingham*, Thomas “Dead Eye” McCurdy*, Robert S. Petriello*, Daniel “Boots” Salotti*
1970— Peter Gallo*, Baptiste “Bap” Manzini*, James C. “Dick” Schrading*, James “Captain” Weir*
1971, 1972 – No Selections
1973—George “Ken” Griffey, Sr., Michael J. Herk, Ed. D.*, Peter “Bud” Roman*
1974— Alex Barantovich*, Charles R. “Jesse” James*, James O. Leeper*, Charles Mahovlich, D.D.S.*, Andy Yartin*
1975— Clair N. Brown*, Frank Janosik*, Joseph McCune*, Roger Rossi*
1976— George J. “Beans” Chacko*, Fred Cox, D.C.*, Bert Sutton*, Albert P. “Bo” Wildman*
1977— Peter L. Cherocci*, George Hays*, George “Jake” Kovalcik*, Elmo Natali*, John “Shag” Wolosky*
1978 – 1995 – No Selections
1996—Bruce Dal Canton*, Joe Gladys*, Ron Necciai, Ollie Payne*, Ulice Payne, Myron “Mo” Pottios, Andy Sepsi*, Paul Wyatt*
1997— Rudy Andabaker*, Al J. “Elmer” Benyak*, Gustave “Gus” Brickner*, James “Mouse” Chacko, Carl Crawley, Jr., Doug Crusan, Frank Lignelli*, Bill Malinchak
1998— Eric Crabtree, Dick Fields*, Leon “Pappy” Johnson*, Fran LaMendola, Don “Ducky” LeJohn*, Jeff Petrucci, Ronald “Ron” Rossi*, Danny Taylor*
1999— Suzy Williams Broadhurst, Mike Bucchianeri*, Bill Contz, Angelo Dabiero, Richard “Dick” DiBiaso*, Sam Havrilak, D.D.S., John “Poppy” Popovich*
2000— Don Asmonga*, Tony Benjamin, Augie Bossu*, Julius Dawkins, Val Jansante*, Joe Montana, Lee Sala*
2001— Henry “Heinie” Adams*, Tom Ballaban*, Eugene Belczyk, Dale Hamer, Bill Robinson*, Joe Sarra*, Jack Scarvel*, George Zuraw
2002— Bernie Galiffa*, Fred Mazurek, William “Bill” Parkinson, Jr.*, Pete Rostosky, Joe Rudolph, James Simms*, Bill Urbanik
2003— John “Chipper” Bruno*, Don Croftcheck, Anthony J. Romantino, Ed. D.*, David “Pivot” Russell, Fred Uhlman, Sr., Danny Warbutton*, Fred Yuss, Ron Yuss*
2004— Melvin B. Bassi, J.D.*, Melvin Boyd, Craig Cotton*, John “Corky” DeMillion*, Ashley Totedo, Scott Zolak
2005— Mitch Bailey*, Craig Fayak, Steve Garban, Stan “Butch” Kemp, Gina Naccarato
2006— Bobby Locke, Greg Paterra, Anthony Peterson, John “Shell” Shelapinsky*, Governor John K. Tener*
2007— James Bayens*, Pete Daley, Sr.*, Brad Ferrara, M.D., Ron Hughes*, Bob Johnson*, Dennis “Bird” Laskey, Tom Parks
2008— James H. “Kayo” Adamson*, John F. Hewitt*, Gary V. Hogan, Joseph M. Kurey, Charles W. “Billy” Russell, Donna DeMarino Sanft, Robert “Red” Worrell*, John “Big John” Wozniak*
2009— Felton Brown, Sr.*, Andy Dzurinko, Fleming Mosely, III Ed. D, Donald Peters, Roger Valdiserri, John Verkleeren, M.D., Judge Reggie Walton
2010— Art Artis*, John Barbero*, Andrew “Buzz” Garnic, Sr., Pete Goimarac Sr*, Mark Gorscak, Stan “Nunnie” Milchovich*, Vic Trilli
2011— Charles Ahlborn, D.M.D., John “Hoss” Hostetler, Charles “Yogi” Jones, Don Law, Michael Moorer, Willie “the Whip” Ross*, Paul Zolak
2012— Fred Angerman, Brian Herman, Darrell Harding, Ben Jones, Walter Malinchak*, Tom Urbanik, Casper Voithofer
2013— Michael Bright, Brian Miller Bowman, Gary Cramer, Bernie Floriani*, William Lee, Ron Paglia, Larry Papini
2014— Milfred “Bubby” Holmes, Maurice Mathieu, John Maczuzak*, Heather Ferrari Milkent, Tony Segzda*, Charles H. “Chuck” Smith, Edward Zuraw*
2015— Bill Blick, Ron Forsythe*, Eugene Gladys, Jack Green*, Phil Pergola, Bill Ryczaj, Yancey Taylor
2016— John Ballein, Ed. D., Keith Bassi, J.D., Bobby Burns, Jim Edwards, Joseph J. Fedorchik, Sr., M.D.*, Ken “KK” Kulak*, Brigadier General David Papak, Wilbert “Barney” Wolfe*
2017— Don Bartolomucci*, Phil Hughes, Joe Margoneri, Scott Nedrow, Daryle Ruby, Joe Salvino
2018— Vinnie Graham, Erbest “Roger” Hotz, Jamont Kinds, Dan LaCarte, Jamie Reader, Jon Konek*
2019— Charel Allen, Ron Bertovich, Rod Fedorchak, Marlon McIntyre, Lenny Smith, Patsy “Dino” DeBardinis*
2020— No Inductees - Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic
2021— No Inductees - Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic
2022— Jon Green, Bob Rosborough, Major Corley*, Billy Connors, Ben McCauley, Jim Dumm
*Deceased
Bold indicates a member of the PA Sports Hall of Fame